Tuesday, August 30, 2011

EME 5050- Journal for Week #1

http://youtu.be/E1JyLYphevc

After watching the video linked above, the students of my EME 5050 class were asked to answer the following question, "Are we doing what is best for our students, or are we doing what is most convenient for us?"

I thought that this was kind of funny, because I was having this exact discussion with one of my fellow teachers this morning before school.

It seems that often times, those in charge have to do what is most convenient (not spending money on technology or even basic supplies for the classroom) in order to make the budget for the school and/or district work.  Most of the time money for new equipment isn't there to begin with.  I know in the area that I teach we get lots of hand-me-down computers from a local agency that does government contract work.  While this is very generous and the computers are mostly decent, it is not the same as brand new technology.

But is this in the best interest of the students? Nope.

According to the textbook we are using for our class, Integrating Technology and Digital Media in the Classroom, teachers are expected by parents (and sometimes administration) to provide students the skills they need to succeed in the tech-savvy society we live in.  Unfortunately, without up-to-date technology, this is sort of impossible. 

My colleague and I came up with a great solution to this problem.  Administration needs to bite the bullet and provide new computers, projectors, interactive white boards, software, and the like to the whole school.  Is this possible or likely? Probably not. But it sure would make teaching "digital kids" a lot easier!

The textbook, and the YouTube video, and really anyone who observes young people today will see just how integrated they are with technology.  To end, I will leave you with a statistic that the video gave.  It said that if Facebook and Twitter were countries, they'd rank 3rd and 6th in size! Wow! How impressive is that?!

6 comments:

  1. Shelly,

    I thought that statistic about facebook and twitter was so interesting. I had to pause it so I could tell my husband!

    That is really generous of those agencies to share their computers with you. Hopefully as new technology emerges, you will get newer computers. I do agree when you said that "administration needs to bite the bullet" but unfortunately I think in public schools it has to go even higher than our administration. So for the time being, it sounds like we both have to make do with what we have. We know how important it is to incorporate the technology so we are going to try to do what is best for our students.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "[T]eachers are expected by parents (and sometimes administration) to provide students the skills they need to succeed in the tech-savvy society we live in.  Unfortunately, without up-to-date technology, this is sort of impossible."

    Is it truly "impossible" to help students develop 21st century skills without the latest technology resources? What about critical thinking, problem solving, creativity, etc.?

    Couldn't even the most up-to-date technology be (mis)used in ways that reinforce outmoded skillsets?

    I'm playing Devil's Advocate to some extent, but what do you think?

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I understand where you are coming from. As an educator, it seems impossible to prepare students for a "tech-savvy" world without the resources. However, I believe something is better than nothing. At my school, we do not have the most up-to-date technology resources, but I have still introduced my students to Microsoft Office by having them type their writing, make powerpoint presentations for book reports, or use Microsoft Excel to depict their data taken from an in-class survey. In addition, assigning in-school research projects so, there are ways to prepare students with some knowledge with the bare minimum.
    Currently, I work at a Title 1 school with 65% Free and Reduced lunch; our school serves a very poor population. With that said, my students know more than me when it comes to technology and I have access to more technology resources and equipment than they do. I think your post was great because it allows for several opinions to be made and experiences to be shared.
    Do you believe that some educators are afraid to teach out of their comfort zone, when technology is concerned? Also, do you think educators are too concerned with core subjects to make time for integrating technology into the curriculum?
    I would love to know what you think. I'm looking forward to hearing from you soon.

    ReplyDelete
  5. @ Dr. Thompson- It is truely not impossible. I guess I was being very drastic in my post. I got on a kick and sort of went to town. It certainly is possible to teach with technology that isn't current, as that is what most of us do. I guess I was just meant it would be really nice to have computers that didnt crash frequently, and that could run more current software.

    @ Nathanael- That is where professional development should come into play. Teachers need to be trained to utilize the technology that we have and how to use it to most benefit the students. This costs money too, so probably it gets pushed to the back burner for us.

    @ Brittany- I know for a fact that a lot of teachers are scared of technology! Several teachers at my school are older, and this makes them scared of computers, etc. We are required to do lesson plans online via a program called Instruction Planner. We also have to use Edline and GradeQuick. They only do the minimum they have to, just to get by. Also, technology can be time consuming if you're not familiar with it. They are too uncomfortable or ashamed to ask for help with these things.
    Also, some people are probably too concerned with core subjects to integrate technology. But, couldn't they use the technology in those areas?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Shelly,

    I completely understand your post about school budgets and those in charge doing what they have to do to "survive". Working at a school with a strong community, our administration is pushing for fundraisers, implementing the latest technology into every classroom. During this school year, every classroom will have a SMART board, with a document camera. This technological advancement is vital in order to keep up with our students' educational needs. I hope that many other schools do the same for our students to succeed.

    As for your comment on the most populous countries, I find it hard to imagine that digital communities are exceeding most countries. I agree with you, it is amazing to think those stats are true! What will the future hold? Scary...

    Brian

    ReplyDelete